Skip to the guide

History of generative art / Chapter 09 · 2010s

Generative Art in the 2010s: The AI Era

This decade saw two paradigmatic shifts for technology and art: the rise of AI and the invention of NFTs. This chapter covers these twin developments, as AI completely reimagines digital expression while NFTs enable digital ownership. Combined, they serve as unparalleled growth catalysts for generative art.

From Le Random’s Generative Art Timeline. Original moment texts by Peter Bauman.

Chapter introduction

Epoch AI separates AI history into three eras based on compute trends. Epoch dates the start of the Deep Learning Era to somewhere between 2010 and 2012. This year thus marks a hugely significant turning point in AI, as the decade in some ways resembles the 1990s of the Internet and the 1960s’ transition from the analog to the digital, featuring several key AI developments, including the breakthrough of Convolutional Neural Networks and the invention of Diffusion models, GANs and DeepDream.

For more context, we suggest [watching or listening (transcript) to our Ch 9 Artist Discussion with Tyler Hobbs, Helena Sarin, Rhea Myers and Gene Kogan.]

In several areas beyond AI this decade takes the themes from our previous chapter(s) and expands upon them with renewed vigor, due to a decade of robust technological growth. As introduced many times previously, AI and blockchain-based art have finally become more prominent parts of this story in a decade marked by ubiquitous social media, renewed institutional interest and a continued boom in tooling developments. While NFTs would not gain popularity until the following decade—and chapter—their introduction and impact begin here. We follow their evolution in detail throughout the decade, examining the themes and developments that continue to shape our story today.

This is also a decade broadly defined by growth and a historically low interest rate environment. Following the previous decade’s twin American-led wars and Global Financial Crisis (GFC) in 2008–2009, the 2010s marked a resetting of the geopolitical-financial order that had settled post-Cold War. For our story, the technology sector experienced the boom in the 2010s it had failed to realize in the previous decade following the dot-com bust, wars and GFC. In the GFC’s aftermath, interest rates remained at historically low levels at 0.25% for half the decade. The Nasdaq index increased over 300% from 2010 to 2019 and the Nasdaq 100 increased nearly 400%, led by growth in the rapidly rising tech giants of Apple, Google, Facebook, Amazon and Netflix.

This technological leap partly explains—and is a result of—corresponding tech developments and compute power increases in the decade. These developments unlocked our ambitions for AI, which had laid dormant as theory until the tech caught up.

What this growth in tech signified—and further spurred—was humanity’s broader adoption of technology across the globe, as computing and network speeds that were unthinkable just a few years ago became possible due to the global proliferation of smartphones. Our pendulum-esque relationship with technology shifted once more—with the latest nadir coming in the '70s, marked mostly by fear—to now blind acquiescence. Smartphones, tablets, smartwatches, VR headsets and a growing number of delightful consumer tech devices meant that the rise of mass media and tech devices in our homes—which this author has mentioned dozens of times in previous chapters—skyrocketed this decade. Not only were tech devices found in our homes, beginning in earnest in the 1980s in the developed world, they were now constantly on our person. They were in our pockets, on our wrists, in our bags and even on our face. They were now part of us, a trend that does not appear to be slowing, which artists like Lauren Lee McCarthy, Sougwen Chung and Tyler Hobbs are responding to in this decade.

Humanity’s relationship with technology was different. This Timeline is the story—going very far back—of how that happened and an examination of our dynamic relationship with technology throughout history. This chapter is the story of how that relationship turned a corner.

Original moment and sources →

Machine vision becomes a generative resource

A block diagram of the AlexNet architecture -- the University of Toronto 'SuperVision' network whose stacked convolution and pooling layers won the 2012 ImageNet challenge.
Diagram by Aston Zhang, Zachary C. Lipton, Mu Li and Alexander J. Smola (Dive into Deep Learning), CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons.

2012

Deep Convolutional Neural Networks Unleashed

Arguably the biggest development in machine learning in decades, deep convolutional neural networks (CNNs or “ConvNets”) revolutionized machine vision. Their power was deployed for the first time relating to creative expression when the SuperVision algorithm from the University of Toronto used CNNs to win the ImageNet Large-Scale Visual Recognition Challenge. Critically, ConvNets were the driving force behind the decade’s upcoming AI developments This paradigm-shifting…

Read the full moment →
Sources for this moment
Figure 2 from Generative Adversarial Nets (2014): generated samples for MNIST, TFD and CIFAR-10, with nearest training examples in the rightmost columns.
Ian J. Goodfellow, Jean Pouget-Abadie, Mehdi Mirza, Bing Xu, David Warde-Farley, Sherjil Ozair, Aaron Courville and Yoshua Bengio. Figure 2, Generative Adversarial Nets, 2014, p. 6. Source: arXiv:1406.2661. Image source.

2014

Ian Goodfellow Introduces GANs

In one of this story’s most relevant moments, Ian Goodfellow and his colleagues at the University of Montreal introduced the world to Generative Adversarial Networks (GANs), revolutionizing—and I don’t use the word lightly—the field of machine learning. GANs consist of two models: a generative model that captures the data distribution, and a discriminative model that estimates the likelihood of a sample being from the…

Read the full moment →
Sources for this moment

2015

Google’s Alexander Mordvintsev Launches DeepDream

2015 stands as a monumental year in this story—up there with 1965 (digital art’s public beginnings) and 1995 (net.art)—as the year AI art properly took off. GANs had been introduced a year earlier and served as a primary catalyst along with this seminal moment, the launch of Google’s DeepDream. These events ensured 2015’s place in history with important work by AI legends Gene Kogan,…

Read the full moment →
Sources for this moment

Artists explore learned images

A grid of sample nude portraits generated by Robbie Barrat's nude-portrait GAN, published by the artist in the README of his own art-DCGAN repository.
Robbie Barrat, sample output from nude-portrait GAN, art-DCGAN, 2018. Courtesy of the artist, via the artist's GitHub repository.

2018

Landscapes and Nude Portraits by Robbie Barrat

In 2017 Robbie Barrat began using Generative Adversarial Networks to make art, producing his first two significant bodies of work, Landscapes and Nude Portraits, which reached collectors in 2018. He had begun his explorations of AI in 2016, with a Bach-imitating LSTM in July and a rapping neural network in November. His initial attempt with landscapes yielded realistic but ultimately unremarkable results, highlighting the…

Read the full moment →
Sources for this moment

Creative coding continues in the browser

The p5.js Web Editor at its 2018 launch, displaying Matthew Kaney’s Tea Time. A later interface for the library initiated in 2013.
Screenshot: Processing Foundation. Tea Time: Matthew Kaney. Web Editor development led by Cassie Tarakajian. Image source.

2013

Lauren Lee McCarthy Creates p5.js

Lauren Lee McCarthy created p5.js roughly twelve years after the initial release of Processing in 2001. P5.js is a JavaScript library that revitalizes the goals of the original Processing project for today’s web environment, where JavaScript—quite different from Java, despite their similar names—has become the dominant Internet-based language. Originating from Processing, designed by Ben Fry and Casey Reas between 2000 and 2001 as a…

Read the full moment →
Sources for this moment
Courtesy of Patricio González Vivo and Jen Lowe.

2015

Patricio González Vivo and Jen Lowe Teach the World Shaders

Patricio González Vivo and Jen Lowe’s incredibly versatile open-source project, The Book of Shaders, has been published in twelve languages and applies to various environments, including Processing, openFrameworks and Three.js. The online book and toolkit have revolutionized the creative environment since their initial publications by teaching the world about the transformative power of fragment shaders. These short programs offer enhanced control and faster rendering…

Read the full moment →
Sources for this moment

Blockchain as provenance and artistic material

Kevin McCoy, Quantum (2014). The original 179-frame animated GIF, preserved without alteration.
Kevin McCoy, Quantum, 2014. Original animated GIF from McCoySpace, the website of Jennifer and Kevin McCoy.

2014

Jennifer and Kevin McCoy’s Quantum

NFTs Enable Digital Ownership While previous explorations of the blockchain existed prior to Jennifer and Kevin McCoy’s Quantum—many of them can be found previously on this Timeline—none presented a complete package of what NFTs would be than the McCoys. Quantum was also, critically, publicly explained and presented the following afternoon, after it was “minted” on May 2, 2014. This legendary presentation by Kevin McCoy…

Read the full moment →
Sources for this moment
Courtesy of Rhea Myers.

2014

Is Art by Rhea Myers

This piece from July 23, 2014, under three months after Quantum is another proto-NFT from 2014, yet it derives inspiration from Duchamp, 1960s Conceptualism and net.art. Other early proto-NFTs include NILIcoin and Quantum from the same year, and Mothership from 2013—all found on the Timeline. The work, published as contract code in 2014 and deployed to Ethereum in 2016, that can be toggled between…

Read the full moment →
Sources for this moment

In conversation

Listen to the chapter

All 118 moments in this chapter

The complete chronology, including works, ideas, exhibitions and the technologies around them.

  1. Desire of Codes, Seiko Mikami
  2. Enter the Turbo-Charged 2010s
  3. ImageNet Large Scale Visual Recognition Challenge
  4. Three.js Released
  5. Cinder Launched
  6. iPad Announced
  7. Instagram Launches
  8. onformative Founded
  9. Characteristics of pattern formation by Jeff Jones
  10. The Artist Is Present by Marina Abramovic at MoMA
  11. Menstruation Machine by Sputniko!
  12. hello world by Kazumasa Teshigawara (qubibi)
  13. Color of words by Gene Kogan
  14. Written Images by Martin Fuchs and Peter Bichsel
  15. Media Archaeology: Approaches, Applications, and Implications by Erkki Huhtamo and Jussi Parikka
  16. Len Sassaman ASCII Tribute on Bitcoin
  17. NONOTAK Formed
  18. Watson Wins Jeopardy!
  19. Deep Convolutional Neural Networks Unleashed
  20. Ghosts in the Machine at the New Museum, New York
  21. Manolo Begins Processing Sketches
  22. Rafaël Rozendaal, Into Time with mirrors
  23. Processing Foundation Begins
  24. Parallel 1 by Harun Farocki
  25. Lauren Lee McCarthy Creates p5.js
  26. BANK by Kevin Abosch
  27. Ascribe Conceptualizes Proto-NFTs
  28. Mothership by Jonathan Monaghan
  29. Beautypi Starts ShaderToy
  30. Taeyoon Choi, Zach Lieberman, Jen Lowe and Amit Pitaru Co-Found the School for Poetic Computation (SFPC)
  31. Jerobeam Fenderson and Hansi3D Begin Oscilloscope Music
  32. Summer by Olia Lialina
  33. Data-Masks (Series) by Sterling Crispin
  34. Vitalik Buterin Publishes Ethereum Whitepaper
  35. Jennifer and Kevin McCoy’s Quantum
  36. Ian Goodfellow Introduces GANs
  37. Tezos Proposed
  38. Art Post-Internet at UCCA, Beijing
  39. Is Art by Rhea Myers
  40. NILIcoin by Nili Lerner
  41. Ten Questions Concerning Generative Computer Art by McCormack et al.
  42. Akihiro Kubota’s ARTSAT1:INVADER Launches Generative Art Satellite
  43. Tyler Hobbs Starts Writing About Generative Art
  44. Stephanie Dinkins Begins Conversations with BINA48
  45. Diffusion Model Invented at Stanford by Jascha Sohl-Dickstein
  46. Google’s Alexander Mordvintsev Launches DeepDream
  47. From the Archives: Art and Technology at LACMA, 1967–1971 at Los Angeles County Museum of Art
  48. Ethereum Officially Launches
  49. Patricio González Vivo and Jen Lowe Teach the World Shaders
  50. Shunsuke Takawo Begins his Daily Coding
  51. Harm van den Dorpel Opens Left Gallery
  52. Drawing Operations by Sougwen Chung
  53. Etheria Is First Ethereum NFT
  54. Journey through the Layers of the Mind by Memo Akten
  55. Oscar Schwartz gives a TEDx Talk on Computational Poetics
  56. Rare Pepes by Joe Looney
  57. Electronic Superhighway (2016-1966) at Whitechapel Gallery, London
  58. Noite de Processing
  59. A Companion to Digital Art by Christiane Paul
  60. Zach Lieberman Begins Daily Instagram Animations
  61. Spectacle, Speculation, Spam by Alan Warburton
  62. Factory of the Sun by Hito Steyerl at MOCA
  63. Zurich HB Flap by Andreas Gysin & Sidi Vanetti
  64. So you want to build a generator by Kate Compton
  65. inconvergent.net Publishes Work on Open-Source Algorithms
  66. Neural Network Written Rap Song by Robbie Barrat
  67. AlphaGo and AlphaFold
  68. Curios Cards: First Art NFT on Ethereum
  69. Matt Hall and John Watkinson Release CryptoPunks
  70. Thinking Machines: Art and Design in the Computer Age, 1959–1989 at MoMA
  71. Open Codes at ZKM Center for Art and Media
  72. Tezos ICO
  73. ERC20 Launches
  74. Creeps & Weirdos by DADA.nyc
  75. CryptoKitties Launches
  76. The Blockchain Art Market Is Here by Jason Bailey (Artnome)
  77. Crystal Towers by Matt DesLauriers
  78. LAUREN by Lauren Lee McCarthy
  79. R.A.R.E Art Labs Launched
  80. The Truelist by Nick Montfort
  81. 1 the Road by Ross Goodwin
  82. Attention Is All You Need
  83. Why Love Generative Art? by Jason Bailey on Artnome
  84. Rare Digital Art Festival #1, New York
  85. Landscapes and Nude Portraits by Robbie Barrat
  86. Christie’s First Art + Tech Summit
  87. SuperRare launches
  88. Tezos Mainnet Goes Live
  89. Christie’s First Sale of an AI artwork
  90. Programmed: Rules, Codes, and Choreographies in Art, 1965–2018 at The Whitney
  91. Chance and Control: Art in the Age of Computers at the V&A
  92. Dieter Shirley and Others Propose the ERC-721 Standard
  93. Memories of Passersby I by Mario Klingemann
  94. Progress by Tyler Hobbs at Galerîa dos Topos Léon, Mexico
  95. BOB by Ian Cheng
  96. Meandering River by onformative
  97. uumwelt by Pierre Huyghe
  98. Chaos Machine by Distributed Gallery
  99. All We’d Ever Need Is One Another by Adam Basanta
  100. Putting the Pieces Back Together Again by Ralf Baecker
  101. A Gutenberg Poetry Corpus by Allison Parrish
  102. On View by Operator
  103. Larva Labs Releases Autoglyphs
  104. Public Key / Private Key by Jennifer and Kevin McCoy
  105. Casey Reas Creates a2p (artist-to-peer)
  106. Automat und Mensch at Kate Vass Galerie
  107. MACHINE HALLUCINATION by Refik Anadol
  108. Inferno by Helena Sarin
  109. CODED FIELD by Rhizomatiks
  110. The Art of Cybersecurity by Brendan Dawes
  111. Rare Digital Art Festival #2, New York
  112. First Contemporary and Digital Art Fair (CADAF) in New York
  113. EONS by Mike Tyka
  114. Notable AI work of 2019
  115. OpenAI Releases GPT2
  116. POEMPORTRAITS by Es Devlin, with Ross Goodwin and Google Arts & Culture
  117. ReRites by David Jhave
  118. Travesty Generator by Lillian-Yvonne Bertram